Take full advantage of our site features by enabling JavaScript.

Following shop Follow shop

AndrewsEnchantedGems

Andrew’s Enchanted Gems

Rumson, New Jersey

|

AndrewsEnchantedGems is a Star Seller!

Smooth shipping

Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies

Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews

Average review rating is 4.8 or higher

Andrew Rosenthal

Following shop Follow shop

Announcement Welcome! Here you will find gems of exceptional quality, ethically sourced, and precision cut by me. As a professional gemologist I can answer any questions you may have about any of the gems available in my shop.

Announcement

Last updated on Nov 15, 2020

Welcome! Here you will find gems of exceptional quality, ethically sourced, and precision cut by me. As a professional gemologist I can answer any questions you may have about any of the gems available in my shop.

Request Custom Order

Contact shop owner

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Featured items

Arizona Peridot, mixed cut 1.00 carats Width 6.08 mm, depth 4.47 mm San Carlos Arizona peridot

Arizona Peridot, mixed cut 1.00 carats Width 6.08 mm, depth 4.47 mm San Carlos Arizona peridot

$120.00

FREE shipping

Montana sapphire 4.43mm x 3.45mm. 0.53 carats teal, blue no heat or treatment

Montana sapphire 4.43mm x 3.45mm. 0.53 carats teal, blue no heat or treatment

$320.00

FREE shipping

Montana sapphire 1.00 ct, emerald cut 1.00 carat blue no heat or treatment, steely blue 5.50 x 4.29 x 4.10 mm

Montana sapphire 1.00 ct, emerald cut 1.00 carat blue no heat or treatment, steely blue 5.50 x 4.29 x 4.10 mm

$510.00

FREE shipping

Montana sapphire 5.05mm x 3.67mm 0.70 ct green/blue color change Montana sapphire, eye clean, some silk. Emerald cut. unheated/untreated

Montana sapphire 5.05mm x 3.67mm 0.70 ct green/blue color change Montana sapphire, eye clean, some silk. Emerald cut. unheated/untreated

$320.00

FREE shipping

All Items

Peach pink lab sapphire 6.90 carats, 9.83 x 9.83 x 7.67 mm. Asscher cut lab sapphire. Precision cut

Peach pink lab sapphire 6.90 carats, 9.83 x 9.83 x 7.67 mm. Asscher cut lab sapphire. Precision cut

$340.00

FREE shipping

Winza sapphire 0.40 carats, 4.00 x 4.00 x 2.83 mm. Octagon step cut. Pink, purple . No treatment. Precision cut Winza sapphire

Winza sapphire 0.40 carats, 4.00 x 4.00 x 2.83 mm. Octagon step cut. Pink, purple . No treatment. Precision cut Winza sapphire

$180.00

FREE shipping

Pink lab sapphire 4.95 carats, 12.61 x 8.81 x 6.29 mm. Brilliant cut oval. Precision cut pink sapphire

Pink lab sapphire 4.95 carats, 12.61 x 8.81 x 6.29 mm. Brilliant cut oval. Precision cut pink sapphire

$280.00

FREE shipping

Peach pink lab sapphire 2.10 carats, 8.27 x 5.43 x 4.42 mm. Baguette step cut. Padparadscha peach pink lab sapphire. Precision cut

Peach pink lab sapphire 2.10 carats, 8.27 x 5.43 x 4.42 mm. Baguette step cut. Padparadscha peach pink lab sapphire. Precision cut

$150.00

FREE shipping

Spinel 0.80 carats, 6.43 x 4.03 x 3.04 mm. Lavender spinel, Sri Lanka. No treatment. Emerald cut

Spinel 0.80 carats, 6.43 x 4.03 x 3.04 mm. Lavender spinel, Sri Lanka. No treatment. Emerald cut

$160.00

FREE shipping

Zircon 0.80 carats, 7.20 x 5.27 x 3.24 mm. Lozenge cut yellow zircon, Sri Lanka. No treatment. Precision cut

Zircon 0.80 carats, 7.20 x 5.27 x 3.24 mm. Lozenge cut yellow zircon, Sri Lanka. No treatment. Precision cut

$140.00

FREE shipping

Sapphire 0.80 carats, 6.90 x 4.12 x 2.74 mm, free form step cut. No treatment. Garba Tula, Kenya, natural sapphire

Sapphire 0.80 carats, 6.90 x 4.12 x 2.74 mm, free form step cut. No treatment. Garba Tula, Kenya, natural sapphire

$200.00

FREE shipping

Imperial topaz 1.05 carats 5.90 x 5.80 x 3.97 mm. Asscher cut. No treatment. Natural imperial topaz, Ouro Preto Brazil

Imperial topaz 1.05 carats 5.90 x 5.80 x 3.97 mm. Asscher cut. No treatment. Natural imperial topaz, Ouro Preto Brazil

$310.00

FREE shipping

Indicolite Tourmaline 6.80 x 3.93 x 3.39 mm 0.85 carats , indicolite tourmaline, Pakistan. No heat or treatment

Indicolite Tourmaline 6.80 x 3.93 x 3.39 mm 0.85 carats , indicolite tourmaline, Pakistan. No heat or treatment

$140.00

FREE shipping

Herkimer diamond 1.30 carats, 10.64 x 5.21 x 4.42 mm, marquis cut. Natural herkimer diamond gem

Herkimer diamond 1.30 carats, 10.64 x 5.21 x 4.42 mm, marquis cut. Natural herkimer diamond gem

$140.00

FREE shipping

Only 1 available and it's in 1 person's cart

Umba sapphire 0.50 carats, 7.27 x 3.73 x 2.45 mm. No heat or treatment. Natural umba sapphire. Tanzania. Rhombus step cut

Umba sapphire 0.50 carats, 7.27 x 3.73 x 2.45 mm. No heat or treatment. Natural umba sapphire. Tanzania. Rhombus step cut

$160.00

FREE shipping

Heliodor 9.27 x 3.81 x 3.83 mm, 1.00 carats. Natural heliodor, Minas Gerais Brazil. Opposing bar cut. No treatment

Heliodor 9.27 x 3.81 x 3.83 mm, 1.00 carats. Natural heliodor, Minas Gerais Brazil. Opposing bar cut. No treatment

$110.00

FREE shipping

Only 1 available and it's in 1 person's cart

Rubellite tourmaline 0.50 carats, 4.98 x 3.93 x 3.22 mm. No treatment

Rubellite tourmaline 0.50 carats, 4.98 x 3.93 x 3.22 mm. No treatment

$130.00

FREE shipping

Almandine-pyrope garnet 5.65 x 3.82 mm, 0.90 carats. Fancy round cut, no treatment. Natural almandine pyrope garnet, Tanzania. No treatment

Almandine-pyrope garnet 5.65 x 3.82 mm, 0.90 carats. Fancy round cut, no treatment. Natural almandine pyrope garnet, Tanzania. No treatment

$120.00

FREE shipping

Light blue lab sapphire 6.80 carats 12.11 x 9.59 x 7.89 mm, custom cushion cut. Periwinkle lab sapphire. Precision cut

Light blue lab sapphire 6.80 carats 12.11 x 9.59 x 7.89 mm, custom cushion cut. Periwinkle lab sapphire. Precision cut

$340.00

FREE shipping

Light blue lab sapphire 9.23 x 9.07 x 6.96mm, custom octagonal step cut. Periwinkle, 4.30 carats, light blue lab sapphire. Precision cut

Light blue lab sapphire 9.23 x 9.07 x 6.96mm, custom octagonal step cut. Periwinkle, 4.30 carats, light blue lab sapphire. Precision cut

$270.00

FREE shipping

YAG(Yttrium aluminum garnet) 9.67 x 7.32 x 5.73 mm , 4.60 carats. Emerald step cut. Precision cut

YAG(Yttrium aluminum garnet) 9.67 x 7.32 x 5.73 mm , 4.60 carats. Emerald step cut. Precision cut

$240.00

FREE shipping

Only 1 available and it's in 1 person's cart

Amethyst 2.95 carats, 10.09 mm x 5.96 mm, lavender purple. Round brilliant cut. Amethyst, Zambia

Amethyst 2.95 carats, 10.09 mm x 5.96 mm, lavender purple. Round brilliant cut. Amethyst, Zambia

$120.00

FREE shipping

Lab spinel 1.80 carats, 7.43 x 4.96 mm, cobalt blue. Portuguese cut

Lab spinel 1.80 carats, 7.43 x 4.96 mm, cobalt blue. Portuguese cut

$130.00

FREE shipping

Amethyst 2.35 carats, 7.71 x 7.69 x 7.49 mm, coctagonal step cut, natural amethyst, Zambia. No treatment

Amethyst 2.35 carats, 7.71 x 7.69 x 7.49 mm, coctagonal step cut, natural amethyst, Zambia. No treatment

$155.00

FREE shipping

Amethyst 5.30 carats, 13.96 x 11.11 x 7.43 mm, natural amethyst, Zambia. No treatment

Amethyst 5.30 carats, 13.96 x 11.11 x 7.43 mm, natural amethyst, Zambia. No treatment

$210.00

FREE shipping

Paraiba tourmaline 5.96 x 4.54 x 3.00 mm, 0.70 carats. Natural paraiba tourmaline . Neon blue. No treatment

Paraiba tourmaline 5.96 x 4.54 x 3.00 mm, 0.70 carats. Natural paraiba tourmaline . Neon blue. No treatment

$240.00

FREE shipping

Amethyst 7.08 x 7.06 x 6.52 mm, 1.95 carats asscher cut. No treatment

Amethyst 7.08 x 7.06 x 6.52 mm, 1.95 carats asscher cut. No treatment

$140.00

FREE shipping

YAG(Yttrium aluminum garnet) 6.87 x 6.87 x 5.07 mm, 2.30 carats, custom design octagon. Emerald/tsavorite green. Precision cut

YAG(Yttrium aluminum garnet) 6.87 x 6.87 x 5.07 mm, 2.30 carats, custom design octagon. Emerald/tsavorite green. Precision cut

$190.00

FREE shipping

Only 1 available and it's in 1 person's cart

Green tourmaline 5.92 x 4.37 x 3.91 mm, 0.80 carats, emerald cut. Olive green with yellow secondary hues. Closed c axis. No treatment

Green tourmaline 5.92 x 4.37 x 3.91 mm, 0.80 carats, emerald cut. Olive green with yellow secondary hues. Closed c axis. No treatment

$110.00

FREE shipping

Umba sapphire, 8.33 x 6.45 x 3.56 mm, 1.05 ct, free form step cut. No heat or treatment, teal

Umba sapphire, 8.33 x 6.45 x 3.56 mm, 1.05 ct, free form step cut. No heat or treatment, teal

$310.00

FREE shipping

Peach pink lab sapphire , 5.40 x 4.59 x 2.93 mm, 0.55 carats, peach pink lab created sapphire, oval brilliant cut

Peach pink lab sapphire , 5.40 x 4.59 x 2.93 mm, 0.55 carats, peach pink lab created sapphire, oval brilliant cut

$110.00

FREE shipping

Lab Alexandrite 7.06 x 5.89 x 4.89, 1.75 carats, AL2O3. Precision cut

Lab Alexandrite 7.06 x 5.89 x 4.89, 1.75 carats, AL2O3. Precision cut

$140.00

FREE shipping

Bicolor lab sapphire 13.53 x 6.86 x 5.87, 6.10 carats, bicolor pink/purple lab grown sapphire, emerald cut. Precision cut

Bicolor lab sapphire 13.53 x 6.86 x 5.87, 6.10 carats, bicolor pink/purple lab grown sapphire, emerald cut. Precision cut

$310.00

FREE shipping

Rhodolite garnet triangle step cut, 10.79 x 5.48 x 3.39 mm, 1.20 carats, no treatment. Natural Rhodolite, Morogoro Tanzania

Rhodolite garnet triangle step cut, 10.79 x 5.48 x 3.39 mm, 1.20 carats, no treatment. Natural Rhodolite, Morogoro Tanzania

$120.00

FREE shipping

Bicolor lab sapphire , 8.95 carats, 19.96 x 8.37 x 6.53 mm, elongated hexagonal step cut, pink/purple bicolor sapphire. Precision cut

Bicolor lab sapphire , 8.95 carats, 19.96 x 8.37 x 6.53 mm, elongated hexagonal step cut, pink/purple bicolor sapphire. Precision cut

$340.00

FREE shipping

Prasiolite:1.20 carats, 7.67 x 4.63 mm. Round brilliant cut prasiolite, green amethyst, natural prasiolite, Brazil. Untreated

Prasiolite:1.20 carats, 7.67 x 4.63 mm. Round brilliant cut prasiolite, green amethyst, natural prasiolite, Brazil. Untreated

$120.00

FREE shipping

Bicolor lab sapphire 4.55 carats, 11.33 x 6.60 x 5.59 mm, bicolor pink/purple sapphire,precision cut lab sapphire, baguette cut

Bicolor lab sapphire 4.55 carats, 11.33 x 6.60 x 5.59 mm, bicolor pink/purple sapphire,precision cut lab sapphire, baguette cut

$260.00

FREE shipping

Bicolor lab sapphire 3.70 carats 8.99 x 6.86 x 5.68 mm, emerald cut.bicolor pink/purple lab sapphire. Precision cut

Bicolor lab sapphire 3.70 carats 8.99 x 6.86 x 5.68 mm, emerald cut.bicolor pink/purple lab sapphire. Precision cut

$220.00

FREE shipping

Topaz 4.20 carats, 10.46 x 6.33 mm, no treatment. White topaz, Nigeria. Round brilliant cut

Topaz 4.20 carats, 10.46 x 6.33 mm, no treatment. White topaz, Nigeria. Round brilliant cut

$170.00

FREE shipping

Only 1 available and it's in 1 person's cart

Prasiolite 4.70 carats, 15.10 x 6.10 x 6.10 mm, emerald cut. Prasiolite, Brazil. No treatment . Emerald cut prasiolite

Prasiolite 4.70 carats, 15.10 x 6.10 x 6.10 mm, emerald cut. Prasiolite, Brazil. No treatment . Emerald cut prasiolite

$160.00

FREE shipping

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Andrew Rosenthal

Contact shop owner

Andrew Rosenthal

Reviews

Average item review

(83)

See reviews that mention:

Loading

Loading

Kikou on Apr 7, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Very nice bicolor tourmaline not as clear as pictured, more dark green than blue. Nice box. Fast shipping in 🇨🇭 Good seller. Many thanks !

Andrew responded on Apr 7, 2024

Ty

Watermelon tourmaline 6.30 carats, 15.00 x 7.80 x 5.90 mm, emerald cut. Bicolor tourmaline, Paprook, Afghanistan. No treatment. Precision cu

Watermelon tourmaline 6.30 carats, 15.00 x 7.80 x 5.90 mm, emerald cut. Bicolor tourmaline, Paprook, Afghanistan. No treatment. Precision cu
Mitchell on Apr 5, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Nice stone, just had a crack that I wish was advertised before the sale.

Andrew responded on Apr 5, 2024

thanks

Herkimer diamond 1.25 carats 7.40 x 4.81 mm, brilliant cut

Herkimer diamond 1.25 carats 7.40 x 4.81 mm, brilliant cut
Gaylen on Feb 1, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Beyond compare, better than expected. This will make a very special piece!

Andrew responded on Feb 1, 2024

thank you! 😊

Pink lab sapphire 5.45 carats, 12.97 x 6.78 x 5.95 mm. Barion emerald cut. Bubblegum pink. Precision cut

Pink lab sapphire 5.45 carats, 12.97 x 6.78 x 5.95 mm. Barion emerald cut. Bubblegum pink. Precision cut
Gaylen on Feb 1, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

STUNNING! Carefully and beautifully packaged. Can't wait to set these into the most glorious earrings

Andrew responded on Feb 1, 2024

thank you! I would love to see a picture of the earrings when they are finished!

Lab sapphire pair, 6.33 x 4.22 mm, 1.25 carats, 6.33 x 4.22 mm, 1.25 carats. Portuguese cut sapphire pair. Precision cut sapphires

Lab sapphire pair, 6.33 x 4.22 mm, 1.25 carats, 6.33 x 4.22 mm, 1.25 carats. Portuguese cut sapphire pair. Precision cut sapphires
sweetpeawhiskeytea on Jan 24, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

It's beautiful, will purchase as many more as I can!

Andrew responded on Jan 24, 2024

thank you!

Herkimer diamond 8.86 x 6.26 x 6.03 mm, 1.75 carats, elongated hexagonal step cut, loupe clean. Herkimer, New York. Herkimer diamond

Herkimer diamond 8.86 x 6.26 x 6.03 mm, 1.75 carats, elongated hexagonal step cut, loupe clean. Herkimer, New York. Herkimer diamond
cprasco1 on Jan 12, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Another breath taking beauty from Andrew! All the gems I've bought from this shop are beautifully cut & always fast, secure shipping! Thank you!

Andrew responded on Jan 12, 2024

thank you! 😊

Lab Alexandrite 9.98 x 7.62 x 6.88 mm, 4.50 carats, lab Alexandrite loose gem, cushion cut. Precision cut

Lab Alexandrite 9.98 x 7.62 x 6.88 mm, 4.50 carats, lab Alexandrite loose gem, cushion cut. Precision cut
Eleven on Jan 9, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Excellent cut! All the facets are polished like glass, no course marks, all even and symmetric. The color is fantastic! Very reasonable price for the carat weight.

Andrew responded on Jan 9, 2024

thank you!

YAG (yttrium aluminum garnet) 7.25 carats, 12.57 x 7.44 x 6.01 mm. Emerald/tsavorite green YAG. Precision cut

YAG (yttrium aluminum garnet) 7.25 carats, 12.57 x 7.44 x 6.01 mm. Emerald/tsavorite green YAG. Precision cut
o2bnvermont on Dec 30, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful! The gem is exactly what I was hoping it would be—the color, cutting, and presentation are superb. I’m absolutely delighted.

Andrew responded on Dec 30, 2023

thank you!

Lab sapphire 3.90 carats, 8.90 x 6.34 mm. Portuguese/brilliant precision cut

Lab sapphire 3.90 carats, 8.90 x 6.34 mm. Portuguese/brilliant precision cut
Roger on Nov 25, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

It was really really pretty

Andrew responded on Nov 25, 2023

thank you Roger!

Herkimer diamond, 7.10 carats, 13.54 x 7.99 mm

Herkimer diamond, 7.10 carats, 13.54 x 7.99 mm
Rudy on Nov 7, 2023

5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful stone that looks just like in the pictures! Color is a great complement to other sapphires in the paler range.

Andrew responded on Nov 7, 2023

Thank you Rudy! im glad you’re happy with your gem. these lab alexandrite sapphires are always a challenge to photograph. Your feedback is most helpful. Thank you!

Lab alexandrite 10.02 x 8.06 x 6.29 mm, 4.50 carats

Lab alexandrite 10.02 x 8.06 x 6.29 mm, 4.50 carats

About AndrewsEnchantedGems

Sales 181

On Etsy since 2020

Montana sapphires, before and after cut
Lab sapphires, rubies, and Yttrium aluminum garnets
Work in progress
On the dop
My machine, and gem lab

Precision cut gems, professional gemologist

Shop members

Andrew Rosenthal

Owner

I’m a precision gem cutter, and certified professional gemologist. Every gem I have for sale was cut and sourced by me personally.

Shop policies

Last updated on Dec 18, 2020

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 2 days of purchase

Seller details

View seller details

Captcha failed to load. Try using a different browser or disabling ad blockers.